Sunday, 3 March 2013

Clash Of The Nyonya Titans - Beef Rendang VS Beef Serondeng

These days, I find myself getting quite worked up over the tiniest thing, no Nitamago in my ramen; Chinese stir-fry being ruined and now this. So what's the problem with Rendang you might ask. Nothing! Absolutely nothing wrong with this fantastic dish. This deceptively dry looking concoction not only has the most intense flavours, it is also buttery soft and melts in the mouth. But my issue does not lie with Rendang alone. Read on....

So during a recent conversation with friends and supperclub diners who wanted to recreate this dish, a certain mentioned ingredient quite frankly drove me to almost boiling point. That culprit is Tamarind. Okay, so you might be wondering what is the big deal about this? Well, let me tell you why. There is no tamarind in Beef Rendang. It simply does not belong there. It's sacrilegious!

After doing a fair bit of googling serious research, I can see why the confusion occurs. Most recipes available online committed the sinful faux pas of putting tamarind on the ingredient list?! Now in order to clarify things, let me first introduce you to the inferior cousin of Beef Rendang.

Ladies and gentlemen.........Say hello to the lovely and demure Beef Serondeng:

Now please welcome the Superstar, the sexy Beef Rendang:

On the face of it, both Beef Serondeng (not to be confused with the normal Serunding/Serondeng which is a meat floss version of this) and Beef Rendang are easily confused due to their similar appearances. However, on closer inspection, you can see that the former is completely dry and coated with crispy grated coconut; the Rendang on the other hand, has a slightly wetter and moist consistency. They are also both prepared and cooked in very different ways.

For Beef Rendang. the meat is braised alongside all the ingredients for hours in coconut milk until it becomes almost dry. The cooking process changes as it cooks; from braising to frying as the coconut milk slowly evaporates and reduces, leaving behind a layer of coconut oil that gently fry and caramelises the meat, yielding a rich and buttery bites.

The different stages of Beef Rendang:

As for Beef Serondeng, the meat is braised in tamarind and water, no coconut milk is used. The fried grated coconut are added only towards the end of cooking to retained their crispy crunchiness. What you get is a very different, completely dry and crispy dish offset by the hint of tangy tamarind.

So now you see the reason behind my frustration.

A noteworthy mention is that to make this dish, try to get your hands on the freshly grated coconut instead of the dried desiccated one. The end result will be so much nicer. A little disclaimer here, my coconut grater is broken and henceforth I had to use the dried desiccated coconut but fret not, a new grater is now in the post, on its way to my lovely kitchen.

(Click here for my Beef Rendang recipe) 

Beef Serondeng

Ingredients (Serves 4)

150g freshly grated or desiccated coconut
3 tbsp sunflower oil (plus more for shallow frying if using freshly grated coconut)
3 tbsp tamarind paste
750g stewing or braising beef (I used brisket here), cut into large 3cm chunks
500ml water
6 kaffir lime leaves
100g gula melaka / palm sugar, grated
sea salt, to taste

For the rempah/spice paste:
12-15 dried red chillies, soaked in warm water for 20 minutes
3 stalk lemongrass
1 tbsp chopped fresh ginger
1 tbsp chopped fresh galangal
1 medium onion, peeled and chopped
3 garlic clove, peeled
1 tbsp ground coriander
1 tsp ground cumin
1 tsp fennel seeds
1 tsp ground turmeric


Heat some oil for shallow frying in a pan. Fry the freshly grated coconut for 2-3 minutes, until golden and crispy. Drain on some kitchen paper. 

Alternatively, if using desiccated coconut, fry in a dry pan over low heat , about 5-6 minutes, until lightly brown. Remove and set aside.

Combine all the ingredients for the rempah in a mortar and pestle and pound to a smooth paste. Alternatively, blitz everything in a food processor.

Heat the oil in a wok/ large pan over medium heat. Add the rempah/spice paste and stir-fry for 12-15 minutes, until fragrant and most of the moisture has evaporated. The paste should have deepened in colour. Add the tamarind and the beef and continue to stir-fry for another 3-4 minutes before adding the water. Bring to the boil and add the kaffir lime leaves, palm sugar and season with sea salt to taste. 

Lower the heat and leave to simmer for 3 hours or more, until most of the liquid has been absorbed and the beef is tender. You may need to adjust the timing. Cook the beef for longer, adding a touch more water if necessary. 

Add the dry-fried coconut and stir continuously until well combined.

Serve with some steamed rice. 


  1. I love your recipe posts, and all the extra information! This one is making me smile, too!

  2. Catherine Horrocks28 October 2013 at 04:21

    Thanks for this. My husband and I were just arguing over whether to put tamarind into rendang. (He thinks yes and I think no).

  3. My pleasure! And I agree with you on the NO :)

  4. YUM!! Before I read your post, I thought definitely Rendang. Now, well I am not so sure. :)



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...